Eight Belles

Eight Belles

Anne M. Eberhardt

KHRA Responds to Eight Belles Incident

The Kentucky Horse Racing Authority issued a statement about Eight Belles.

The Kentucky Horse Racing Authority released a statement May 5 regarding Eight Belles, who was injured and subsequently euthanized after the May 3 Kentucky Derby Presented by Yum! Brands (gr. I). It followed demands by People for Ethical Treatment of Animals for changes in the horseracing industry.

“We are saddened by the loss of Eight Belles during the 134th running of the Kentucky Derby last Saturday," the statement said. "Our hearts go out to Rick Porter, Larry Jones, and every member of Eight Belles’ connections. While injuries such as those sustained by Eight Belles are infrequent to Thoroughbred horse racing, it does not lessen the tragedy when they occur.

"The Kentucky Horse Racing Authorlty has been constantly reviewing safety issues and will continue to monitor research and development in that area. The KHRA is concerned about the health and welfare of Thoroughbred race horses and remains actively involved in all safety aspects of Thoroughbred racing.

"All horses are examined by a KHRA veterinarian prior to racing to ensure they are sound and free of injury on race day. The KHRA has enacted race-day medication rules designed to protect not only the horses, but the jockeys as well. The KHRA will remain vigilant in seeking ways to protect all of the athletes involved in horse racing, and working with racing jurisdictions from other states, as well as national and international organizations.

"For example, an injury reporting system is now in place nationally, and Kentucky has been providing data since the inception of the system. It is hoped that this data can be used to make recommendations to enhance the safety of racing. Likewise, the KHRA will continue investigating injuries occurring during or after a race. In light of the Eight Belles tragedy, the KHRA intends to enhance its protocols in this area. The KHRA will use this information to study and recommend improvements related to the safety of racing.

"People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals sent the KHRA a letter requesting that certain actions be taken. One statement indicated Thoroughbreds should not be trained or raced before their third birthday, however, the KHRA has no scientific evidence to support the need to make this change."

The statement noted Dr. Larry Bramlage, on-call veterinarian for the American Association of Equine Practitioners, said: "As soon as Thoroughbreds are physically mature, they should start effective training. It is most desirable not to let the bone formation apparatus atrophy after growth, and then require it to be re-created. The most effective training takes advantage of the blood supply and cell population that contributed to growth, and converts it to forming bone in response to training. Scientific evidence shows such horses have longer careers and are more successful."

PETA suggested racing should be limited to synthetic surfaces or turf tracks. The KHRA said research is ongoing on the safety of dirt and synthetic surfaces, and it would be premature to rush to judgment on the exclusive use of any particular surface at this time.

The KHRA said it will continue to monitor the research on the safety of track surfaces. Another suggestion has been to reduce the number of races, but the KHRA said it has no scientific evidence to support that change in schedule.

Jockey Gabriel Saez, who rode Eight Belles in the Derby, has been targeted by PETA for allegedly misusing his whip. The KHRA said the whip is a tool used by jockeys to direct and control the horse during the course of a race and "provides safety for all participants in the race, including other horses and riders, by reducing contact with other horses, as well as the rail."

Abuse of the use of a whip is a violation of Kentucky racing regulations. Kentucky racing stewards have taken disciplinary action against jockeys who have abused the use of a whip during a race. Kentucky stewards are required to review the videotape of a race before it can be declared official.

"Kentucky stewards reviewed videotapes of the Derby and saw no evidence of a violation of any racing regulation by Mr. Gabriel Saez during the course of the race," the KHRA statement said.